Ada and Baines relationship was very complicated from
the beginning. She goes to Baines for help, but he turns her down at first. He
finally agrees to help her and he takes her to the piano. It’s there that he
realizes that he likes her and also likes hearing her play the piano. Baines
makes a deal with Ada’s husband that if Alisdair gives him the piano and
lessons from Ada that he would give him some of his land. So Alidair agrees and
the lessons with Ada and Baines soon begin. At first the lessons are innocent
and nothing really goes on, but quicker than you know it, they become something
more. Baines wants to see Ada and he wants to touch her. He makes another deal with her that if she
comes to his place and does as he says, then he will giver her the piano back,
but she has to come one day for each black key on the piano. She agrees with
the deal. You can tell that she soon doesn’t care about getting the piano back,
she’s just doing it because she wants to do it.
Although Baines is rough at times, I don’t think
anything they did was rape. Ada agreed to everything and when Baines was asking
too much from her, she would say that it would cost him more than one key.
Baines didn’t hesitate and would agree right away. I would say that he was
blackmailing her though, but she could have walked away even if it meant
leaving her piano behind. If she would have said no in the beginning then none
of this would have happened, but Baines ends up showing her love and compassion,
which is what she was looking for and what she needed. I don’t think there was
any rape involved because Ada had some control over the situation, but she
chose to stay.